Skip to main content
Home
Donate
  1. Home
  2. Press
Press

Indiana Senate Advances Bill to Kill an Ongoing Court Case and Give the Legislature Unprecedented Judicial Powers

HB 1235 Sets a Dangerous Precedent by Inviting All Current and Future Defendants in Litigation in Indiana to Run to the Statehouse When Losing in Court, Undermining the Constitution's Checks and Balances.

Washington, D.C., February 28, 2024 – The City of Gary’s landmark legal case, City of Gary v. Smith & Wesson Corp., is under threat of annihilation thanks to a bill, HB 1235, that has now advanced through the Indiana Senate. HB1235 cleared the Senate with a 33-15 vote rejecting 23 years of Indiana law only shielding lawful conduct from liability. The common sense policy was defeated.

This legislation undermines the checks and balances established by the Constitution by enabling one branch of government to overpower another by the legislature giving itself judicial power. In this instance, the legislature is aggressively performing at the behest of a single industry – the gun industry – to prevent the courts from carrying out their judicial duties.

“This is an outrageous attack not just on the city of Gary’s case, but also on the Constitution itself,” says Philip Bangle, Senior Litigation Counsel for Brady. “This is not about the merits of Gary’s case, which have been found valid by the courts no less than three times on appeal. This is about Indiana citizens' and municipalities’ ability to seek justice in the courts. Allowing the legislature to usurp the judiciary is a slippery slope. If this bill is signed into law, it will reshape the justice system for generations to come. Any person – or corporation – with ample resources or special interest engaged in litigation in Indiana will see this as an invitation to simply appeal to the legislature to intervene if they are losing in the courts. Hoosiers deserve better, they deserve their day in court. They deserve justice.”

Proponents of HB 1235 have made grossly erroneous and widely debunked arguments in support of this bill.Read more here. Hoosiers are urged to call upon Governor Holcomb to VETO HB 1235.

###

Brady: United Against Gun Violence is the nation's oldest gun organization working to free America from gun violence. We believe that changing laws alone won’t end our nation's gun violence crisis; we must also change hearts and minds. That’s why we take a comprehensive approach to end this epidemic: change the laws, change the gun industry, and change the conversation about guns in America.

GT Nov9 Nov29

Double Your Impact For a Safer Future

A gift to Brady expresses a belief in safer families, stronger communities, and a future free from gun violence. Right now, you’re getting early access to Brady’s GivingTuesday 2X match. Give now and every dollar can go twice as far toward our $100,000 goal.

Double My Impact!