Brady and Sommers Schwartz, P.C. File Lawsuit Against Michigan Sporting Goods Store Over Straw Purchase That Ended in Murder

Family of Firearm Victim Alleges National Gun Retailer is Liable in the Death of Daniel Banaszak, Sr.

Washington, D.C., June 16, 2023 – Brady and co-counsel Matthew Turner at Sommers Schwartz, P.C., on behalf of the family of Daniel Banaszak, Sr., filed a lawsuit today in the Circuit Court for Allegan County in Michigan against Dunham’s Sports for negligently and unlawfully selling a firearm to a “straw purchaser” that was used to kill Daniel Banaszak, Sr. that same day.

The suit alleges that on August 6, 2020, Dunham’s Sports, located in South Haven, Mich., knowingly violated the law and its duties as a licensed firearms dealer by selling a firearm to a straw purchaser despite clear indicators that she was not the actual purchaser.

The shooter, who was prohibited from possessing firearms due to a prior felony conviction, accompanied the straw purchaser to the gun counter, was visibly agitated throughout the transaction and paid for the gun himself. These indicators, along with the others alleged in the complaint, gave Dunham’s Sports more than sufficient information to spot and stop the unlawful straw purchase. Yet, Dunham’s Sports chose to deliberately ignore these dangerous signs, sold the firearm, and did not call law enforcement. The straw purchase sale was caught on camera. Following the sale, the straw purchaser transferred the firearm to the shooter, who used that gun to murder Banaszak within hours of the illicit purchase.

Straw purchases are one of the primary mechanisms by which individuals with felony convictions and others legally prohibited from acquiring or possessing firearms illicitly acquire firearms. In this case, the straw purchaser was acting on behalf of an individual with a disqualifying felony conviction. .

The deadly consequence of Dunham’s Sports failure to act responsibly and lawfully underscores why it is so important for gun dealers to train, monitor and supervise their employees to stop and report straw sales. Banaszak’s family bought this lawsuit with the goal of reforming Dunham’s Sports’ negligent and unlawful practices and preventing future straw purchases that supply other violent criminals.

Douglas Letter, Brady’s Chief Legal Officer, said:

“Nearly 90% of Michigan voters support background checks for gun purchases, which bar gun purchases by people who should not have them. The facts are clear that, in this case, Dunham’s Sports did not perform its duty and should not have facilitated an obvious straw purchase which ended in a very preventable tragedy.”

Matthew Turner of Sommers Schwartz said:

“This might be the most obvious straw sale purchase that I have ever seen. In the form that the law requires to be completed prior to a sale, the purchaser answered honestly that she was buying the gun for someone else. Instead of immediately stopping the sale, the employee from Dunham’s suggested that she change the answer and then went forward with the sale. The gun laws on the books cannot protect people from violence when dealers like Dunham’s act dangerously and unreasonably.”

Stephen Banaszak, son of the victim, said:

“My father would still be alive today if Dunham’s Sports had not acted irresponsibly and unlawfully. My family and I have unfortunately experienced firsthand the destruction that guns can cause when in the hands of people who should not have them. I am a gun owner myself and believe that negligent gun dealers must be held accountable and take responsibility when they sell guns in straw sales."