Florida, June 6, 2011

In 2011, Florida Governor Rick Scott signed a bill making Florida the first state in which it was illegal for any physician to “ask questions concerning the ownership of a firearm” or “harass...a patient about firearm ownership during an examination.” The stated purpose of the law was to protect patient “privacy.” Under the law, doctors could be censored, fined, or penalized through the loss of their license to practice if the Florida Board of Medicine found they violated the law.

The fight over “Docs vs. Glocks” started when a pediatrician in Ocala asked the mother of a young child whether she kept guns in the home. She refused to answer, saying, “whether I have a gun has nothing to do with the health of my child.” But, as Brady stated in our suit, 65 children and teenagers are shot every day in America, and eight of them die; one-third of American homes with children under 18 have a firearm in them; and more than 40% of those households store their guns unlocked, with a quarter of those homes storing them loaded. So, guns do have something to do with the health of America’s children.

Pediatricians are trained (and explicitly advised by the American Academy of Pediatrics) to question parents about the presence of open containers of bleach, swimming pools, and balloons. It’s part of their job to educate parents about potentially lethal dangers around the home. Why, then, is an inquiry into firearms the threat to personal privacy?

Representing a number of Florida doctors, Brady and pro bono partner law firm Ropes & Gray brought suit to challenge the law under the First Amendment. We argued that, under the First Amendment, doctors should have the right to give their best advice to patients when it comes to safety. This individual right is especially important in this context, as it ensures the safety of individuals, families, and communities in Florida.

The case resulted in a landmark decision by the Eleventh Circuit striking down the law as unconstitutional. Even more, Florida was forced to pay over one million dollars in attorneys’ fees because the law was found to violate constitutional rights. This decision and award was a message to states to think twice before enacting or defending laws that put lives -- especially children’s lives -- at risk just to boost the gun lobby.

US Supreme Court


US Supreme Court

For more than 30 years, Brady’s legal team has been the nation’s only law group fighting on behalf of victims and communities to prevent gun deaths and injuries.

We've argued and won before state supreme courts, trial courts, and federal appeals courts, arguing or filing legal briefs in 44 states, and helping win important victories in the United States Supreme Court. Brady's Legal Alliance works with hundreds of lawyers and firms that contribute their passion and time — pro bono — to reform the corporate gun lobby and secure justice for the victims and survivors of gun violence.

Read More
More firearms make us safer


More firearms make us safer

Understanding the issues and supporting common-sense solutions is the only way to fight America’s gun violence epidemic. Everything you need to know from the latest legislation and Brady reports to key statistics and personal stories can be found here. Share it with your friends as well. There is a lot of misinformation out there that needs to be corrected - be an educated activist.

Read More

By continuing to browse, you consent to the use of cookies on this site.